Classic Flavors

  • A container of Odd Fellows vanilla French ice cream with four scoops on top, set against a two-tone background with coral and pink hues.

    Vanilla Bean

    The most popular, and most complex ice cream flavor in the world. Our vanilla ice cream is made with real Madagascar vanilla beans.

    Contains: dairy, eggs

  • A cup of chocolate chip ice cream from Odd Fellows with three scoops against an orange background

    chocolate chunk

    A rich mousse-like chocolate ice cream loaded with melt-in-your-mouth 64% dark chocolate chunks. It’s light, it’s dark, it’s everything!

    Contains: dairy, eggs

  • A cup of vanilla ice cream with colorful sprinkles in an Odd Fellows branded cup, against a red and pink background.

    sprinkles

    Sweet cream ice cream with rainbow sprinkles. Sprinkles was invented the night before opening day, when Chef Sam decided the menu needed a kid-friendly flavor. It has since become one of our most popular flavors among adults.

    Contains: dairy, eggs

  • A cup of Odd Fellow's cookies and cream ice cream topped with three scoops of cookies and cream ice cream with cookie chunks, against a pink and blue background.

    cookies & cream

    We blended ultra velvety sweet cream ice cream with a thorough dusting of soft chocolate cookie crumbs; an OddFellows upgrade to a tried and true classic.

    Contains: dairy, eggs, gluten

  • Three scoops of pink strawberry ice cream in a branded cup on a pink surface with a blue background.

    Strawberry Jam

    The third wheel in the classic ice cream triple threat, our strawberry is not to be looked over. Our creamy strawberry ice cream has swirls of fresh strawberry jam bringing this to the next level

    Contains: dairy, eggs

  • A cup of Odd Fellows French ice cream with peanut butter s'mores flavor, filled with three scoops of ice cream, against a colorful pastel background.

    Peanut Butter S'mores

    Peanut butter ice cream with graham cracker crumbs, marshmallows, & chocolate chunks. This flavor was a collaboration with American rock band - and our Williamsburg neighbors - LCD Soundsystem.

    Contains: dairy, eggs, gluten, nuts

  • A cup of cookies and mint ice cream with three scoops on top, in a branded cup from OddFellows with a colorful, geometric pattern, against a two-tone background of orange and pink.

    Cookies & mint

    Fresh mint ice cream mixed with chocolate cookie crumbles. The love child of mint chip and cookies & cream. You’re welcome

    Contains: dairy, eggs, gluten

  • A cup of Odd Fellows coffee ice cream with three scoops on top, placed on a light pink surface against a red background.

    coffee crunch

    Coffee ice cream - rich, slightly bitter, almost universally beloved. Ours improves on the classic coffee and cream combination with the introduction of “coffee soil” - a housemade textural and flavor inclusion.

    Contains: dairy, eggs, gluten, almond flour

  • Three scoops of passionfruit, apricot, and pistachio ice cream in a colorful cup against a red and pink background.

    Passionfruit Apricot Pistachio

    Tangy, tart passionfruit ice cream, swirls of sweet apricot jam and pieces of pistachio. This sunny ice cream is like cruising oceanside with the top down on a hot summer day

    Contains: dairy, eggs, nuts

  • Salted Caramel Toffee

    Salted Caramel Toffee

    Salted Caramel Toffee starts with a luscious sweet cream base, swirled with ribbons of golden salted caramel and packed with crunchy, chocolate-dusted toffee pieces. Every scoop is a perfect balance of sweet and salty, creamy and crunchy. It’s a timeless flavor combination elevated into a truly crave-worthy dessert.

    Contains: dairy, eggs, nuts

  • Cookie Jar

    Cookie Jar

    Dive into the ultimate cookie lover’s dream with Cookie Jar! A rich, creamy sweet cream base loaded with chunks of chocolate chip cookie dough, crushed chocolate sandwich cookies, and a burst of rainbow sprinkles in every scoop.

    Contains: dairy, eggs, gluten

  • Brooklyn Blackout

    Brooklyn Blackout

    Get ready for a sweet, indulgent ride through the streets of Brooklyn with Brooklyn Blackout: a flavor so decadent, it’s practically a New York City legend. Rich, velvety chocolate ice cream swirls with deep layers of moist chocolate cake and is crowned with a decadent, fudgy chocolate fudge ribbon that will have your taste buds doing a happy dance.

    Contains: dairy, eggs, gluten